Alright, let’s talk about this Mentalist vs Psych thing, you know? I watched them both, so I can tell ya a thing or two. Don’t expect no fancy words from me, though, I just say it like it is.
First off, Psych. That show, it’s like a good laugh with your neighbor over the fence. Shawn, that fella, he pretends he’s a psychic, but he ain’t. He’s just real observant, like my old hound dog sniffing out a squirrel. He sees things other folks miss. The show, it’s funny, you know? They got jokes, and they solve crimes, but it ain’t too serious. It’s more like, “Oh, look at that silly Shawn, he’s funny, but he catches the bad guy anyway.”
- Psych is funny.
- Shawn ain’t a real psychic.
- They solve crimes, but it’s not too serious.
Now, The Mentalist, that’s a whole different kettle of fish. That Patrick Jane fella, he used to be a fake psychic, but now he just uses his brain. He’s like, real smart, you know? He sees things, he figures things out. But the show, it ain’t funny. It’s serious, sometimes even dark. It’s about a man hunting down a bad guy who hurt him real bad. It’s about revenge, and it’s heavy.
See, Psych, it’s like a sunny day, you know? Light and breezy. The Mentalist, it’s more like a cloudy day, maybe even a storm coming. Both good shows, mind you, just different. One makes you laugh, the other makes you think, and maybe even shed a tear or two.
Some folks say Psych came first, by a couple of years. Maybe so, maybe not. I don’t keep track of that stuff. I just watch ’em when they’re on. And I can tell ya, they ain’t the same. Psych is more like those episodic shows, you know? Each week is a new case, and it’s wrapped up nice and neat. The Mentalist, it’s got a bigger story going on, a whole arc about catching this Red John fella. It’s like watching a whole season-long movie broken into episodes.
They both got crime-fighting men, yeah, but they’re different kinds of men. Shawn, he’s a goofball, but he’s got a good heart. Patrick Jane, he’s more serious, more intense. He’s been through some stuff, you can see it in his eyes. He’s like a wounded animal, always on guard.
People online, they argue about which one is better. Some say Psych is better because it’s funny, others say The Mentalist is better because it’s got a fancy plot, you know, more complex. Me? I say they’re both good, just different. It depends what you’re in the mood for. You want a laugh? Watch Psych. You want something serious? Watch The Mentalist. It’s like choosing between apple pie and a steak. Both good, just different tastes.
And that’s the truth of it, plain and simple. No need for fancy book learnin’ to understand that. They both got their charms, they both got their flaws. You watch ’em, you decide which one you like better. Or heck, like ’em both, just like I do. Ain’t nothin’ wrong with that.
Now, some folks online, they talk about psychologists and mentalists. Said a psychologist is a doctor, helps folks with their problems. A mentalist, well, they reckon they can read minds, like them folks with the crystal balls. But these shows, they ain’t about that science stuff. It’s entertainment, pure and simple. They take a little bit of this, a little bit of that, and mix it all up into a story. And that’s what makes ‘em good.
So there you have it. My two cents on Mentalist vs Psych. No fancy words, just plain talk. Hope it makes sense to ya.
Tags: [Psych, The Mentalist, TV Shows, Crime Drama, Comedy, Shawn Spencer, Patrick Jane, Mentalist vs Psych, TV comparison]
